So will it be happening or no?

I personally think the random drawing of the killer will work, and then we just work together as a team, the killer and the one to die to work out the post and how it will work, the clues left behind and everything.

Though this also makes the roleplay a bit of a game, and could end quickly if the ones in the roleplay are unable to figure out who it is, unless you will have a character that pulls things back on track if we all start accusing the wrong people?

Also, why not have kind of like Alter Ego for a few characters? that way they can still contribute to a degree without directly interfering. Just another idea to toss out there aside from the afterlife, which would be humorous.