Well, that difference changes the entire experience, but that's another topic altogether. 

However, if someone gives you the critique you mentioned, it probably meant "Your posts are difficult to understand to me." It may or may not have been communicated clearly, but that's beside the point. Either how, you can choose to respect this, or dismiss it. However, respecting it doesn't automatically mean going full-on one-liners. I mean, as I mentioned in my previous post, it's probably fixed by putting small descriptions of what is most essential to know before the expositions each paragraph. Like for example; "The room smelled of roses." Before going into detail about the effect the smell has on your character, the nuances of the smell on the atmosphere, or whatever you want to portray. Just adding this sentence before the exposition will make things clear to co-players; they can easily understand and identify the building blocks you're giving them.

So yeah, I'm not really sure where you're coming from when you point out it's all just preference. Unless understanding an entire post or not should be counted as preference, but that'd be rather silly a statement, don't you agree?