For sure.

Though, would people want to continue off of where we left it? Nallore had sent me the old DM's plans (So many spoilers... :/) so we could keep going in that direction.
Or would you rather we start fresh considering we'll be getting people who weren't around for the start of the last one?

Starting fresh also means we can effectively decrease the Player/ODST count, which me and Nallore over PM suspected as being part of the issue. We had so many players that we were sort of forced to separate into smaller divisions, which ultimately got a lot of people less engaged. Would of worked on a site solely dedicated to that one RP, not as effective on a multi-RP site like the Guild.