Nope, that certainly sounds reasonable. Discussion and debate is always welcome on concepts introduced, its how we, as writers, hash out details which serve to shape a world. That's important in my opinion. 

I've made my case :) and I'm sticking to it. 
But just to know if the judge is on my side (despite the jury lol) is my idea acceptable to you? You are technically, apart of the debate process, I'm assuming.