Yep Seraph was right this was not going to be no easy feat, as he watched her Elizabeth just seemed to make a weird hand gesture involving her forehead and her hands put together, a way of thinking perhaps? Who really knew whatever made it easier to process he supposed. To the side Seth was standing silently, even Seraph could see he was close to laughing, the man was incorrigible when it came to irony. Seraph quickly shot him a look telling him if he dared to laugh then he was gonna get out of this chair and come put him in a nelson. Seth was quick to cover his mouth and push it off as himself yawning, the last thing needed right now was for Seth to go off in a laughing fit because this earth girl was making weird hand gestures so she could think. Seraph sat there silently for a good amount of time as the girl made all sorts of different gestures, at one point he was pretty sure she had pinched herself, it had been while since he last came to earth but it seemed like maybe they earth inhabitants were more crazy then most in the spiral if this is how they handled thinking. Eventually when she seemed content with her thoughts Elizabeth looked at Seraph and spoke again asking him another question.

"Alright, next question: let's assume I believe you, at least in part. a) Why should I trust you over them-"

Pointing her thumb at the entrance to the cellar she continued her line of inquiry.

"and b) What do you want with me? I'd rather not go out there with those things looking for me, but I'm not about to trade one kidnapping for another."

Seraph sighed when he heard the word kidnapping, all that thinking she did and she was under the illusion that he was trying to kidnap her instead of the Wrath's. This was part of the reason he didn't want to come to earth, once people on earth reached a certain age, it was so hard for them to grasp the fact that there is heck of a lot more out there then they think. An when they see it first hand, they always are skeptical and come to concussions that are ridiculous, never seeing the obvious truth even if its in front of their eye's.

"Perhaps your not understanding the gravity of the situation your in, or perhaps you do and your going into denial. But even you must have noticed that I was trying to save you not kidnap you. I didn't pick you up and carry you away from them Wrath's you went with me willingly, so the use of the word kidnapping is the wrong word to use in this case. You would be right in assuming that I did not just happen to show up tonight when you got attacked that much is true, I was sent here to find you, however when you kicked me in the stomach I was merely trying to get something to eat, finding you there with Wrath's hot on your trail was coincidence, and a nice coincidence to be honest. I guarantee you if they had captured you that the horror you would be in right now would be... how do you say... overwhelming."

Seraph became silent as he removed he wand from his belt and pointed it at the floor in front of him, the crystal glowing a bottle of fire hit the floor taking the form of a footstool. Propping his feet up on the flames he continued to speak.

"Why should you trust me over them, thats a simple answer... because I am the only one besides my friend Seth here on this planet right now who can protect you from them. But let me be frank, I can't and won't force you to stay, as I mentioned I am not here to kidnap you, I came here to bring you back with me to Wizard City because I was asked too, because there are evil forces at work and they want you. Like I said before the reasons are unknown at this point, thats how destiny and fate work a lot of the time. But if you want to leave then I won't stop you, so you can go outside and take your chances with Alazar and his army of walking horrors, but from experience I guarantee you won't make it five feet from this cellar."

Seraph put his feet down as he got up replacing his wand in his belt and walked past Elizabeth, walking to the stairway to the entrance he put his hand up and looked at her speaking.

"My question to you is simple. Who would you rather put your trust in? Me or Alazar? Choice is yours Elizabeth so decide, you can walk out of here right now no questions asked and accept whatever fate awaits you out there or you can stay here where no harm will come to you, until a time that we can leave back to Wizard City, far away from the Wrath's and their clutches. Either way it goes, you are now a part of this if you want to be or not, and they will not stop hunting you. That I can promise you without a doubt in my mind."