Okay no debate got drawn up the first time so let's try this.

Basic idea: we would play as a new knightly order in a land torn in half by civil war. The knights are tasked with picking a side to stabilize the region, and dealing with foreign invaders raiding towns and villages.

Setting: a deep valley naturally protected by sheer cliffs with only a single small land entrance big enough for a single person to fit through and a opening to thhe far south leading to the ocean. Two castles lay in the valley on opposite sides (west and east) with three villages each and a single port.

Order: Knights of Audacity. The newly formed order has a hall just east of the land entrance to the valley. It is two stories tall with a underground training area and smithy which leads into a sealed room where the knights hold counsel.