[quote=Tick]
Mario Kaizo's incredibly entertaining, so long as I'm not playing it. ;]Do you need a rom for Papers, Please? It's technically a modern PC game...it's just got an intentionally old-gamey style....I was sort of cheating, there. If you're looking for actual older games.
[/quote]

Nah, I looked it up. It's Indie, but it fits the criteria somewhat.