[quote=@PlatinumSkink]
... A familiar that was mistaken for a Witch?

... Doesn't that, like, mean that the actual Witch is, like... absolutely friggin' monstrous?


... Also, do familiars have barriers? Suppose they might have some kind of thing, but lesse. What does that do with my plan that Monika had become scared and hidden herself within the barrier in question, after having, like, just become a Magical Girl several moments before? Uh. Is it equally hard to escape a barrier of a familiar? Um. ... Nope, now I'm feeling a whole lot of doubt at what I'm doing. XD
[/quote]

The only person who mistook the familiar for a Witch was Minerva, who has been a Magical Girl for less than 24 hours. Nobody else has seen it, physically, to confirm its identity. Naturally, being the same fundamental beings, Witches and Familiars are hard to distinguish using nothing but a flashing soul gem.

So, um... outplayed.

[quote]Can I just point out that Kyubey has like... 2/100 chance of being there if this is parallel to the Madoka events of any timeline? Or are we saying that every incubator goes by that alias? [/quote]

It has never been specified which timeline we're in. Also, time zones.