I mean, they always begin and end with people just wandering around wondering when others are going to interact with their characters, so what fun are they? In all honesty, I had a really good school Roleplay stretch from January all the way until June, so they certainly aren't impossible. They aren't greatly possible, either, and usually need some sort of "catch" in order to be interesting.

In fact, I only enjoy slice-of-life Roleplays [i]when[/i] there is some sort of "catch" involved.

Naturally, I don't consider superhero, Disney, crossover or supernatural-based high schools to be very original, but some can be executed surprisingly well, so I'm not going to knock them down at well. I do feel like they're a bit overdone considering how many exist on the Guild, though.