[quote=@BrokenPromise]
In particular I'm talking about 4 comments down were everyone and the GM take turns picking apart a user's post. I read the post, and their criticism isn't wrong, but it feels a little excessive? Wouldn't this have been better taken to PMs where everyone involved could have saved face?

[/quote]


I wouldn't really call that picking apart the post. The 4th comment in mention is really only on one thing. So is the followup by a different person saying "Yeah he just about summed it up". The GM's response is a debatable, but that's not for me to say.

It's fairly basic writing etiquette that was neglected in context of the criticism. Maybe it's because I have thick skin at this point, but the comment comes off fine to me.