[quote=@BrokenPromise]But what I'm concerned about is [b]not[/b] that people are voicing their opinion about a particular post, but that so many people are saying the same thing. I don't think that level of repetitious criticism is warranted on the first post in an RP, certainly not before the "offender" has had a chance to confirm if they are going to take the criticism to heart or not. 
[/quote]


Oh, I totally understand your qualm with the repetition. I was attacking the notion of the criticism itself being too aggressive. I can state that I have only seen that once or twice on the Guild thus far, so if my experience is anything to go by then it is not normal behavior.

Am jealous of your experience with Marvel. I've worked a few times with the editors of a few small authors, but nothing of that level. What an opportunity.