[@Korbanjaro]

From what I understand, the goal is Marvel-esque supers, not overly powerful or possessing too many unrelated powers at once, but still powerful. So within that framework, both your characters probably are acceptable.

Spud's planning a magic-based reluctant/anti-hero super and I'm planning on an infant lab experiment super that's sort-of Captain America in his outlook, so either of your characters would provide a new perspective and lead to interesting character dynamics. What's a good superhero team without the clash of personalities?