Now those concerns are completely reasonable, however this isn't an issue of whether Gil can win the fight. The question is if he can instantly win with a power that takes 0 effort and can instantly kill anyone in the roleplay no matter what they do. No one is implying he can't win if he takes the fight at all seriously. I will say again Gilgamesh or Magnus could easily be the strongest characters in the RP. To say Magnus should be made into pulp because it's more "fair" is completely false. It is only being implied some, not all the weapons may not penetrate armor. Also to specify there is no magic in warhammer 40k