[quote=@Double]
<Snipped quote by Letter Bee>

Wait, you made a GM post and left it uncertain if actions were successful? Dude it's called a "GM Post" for a reason. You use those kinds of posts precisely [i]for[/i] determining whether or not attacks or actions are successful in a battle scenario. Imagine if you rolled to attack in a D&D game and the DM just shrugged and expected you to figure out for yourself if the attack hit or missed.
[/quote]

Ah, I mean, I phrased the actions such that the players can put up an IC defense against Walpurgisnacht's attacks; that's what I meant.

But they didn't, it seemed.

So those succeeded.