[@Lugubrious]
The issue is that it's a LOT of clutter. Like, anyone coming in here and reading this stuff will be very confused. Heck, it'd prolly be difficult to find old posts and such, because you don't know which is Canon and which isn't. 

I'd suggest just sticking the "Loser" in a Hider in the bottom of the Winner's post, but otherwise deleting the content of the Loser Post. That way the only "Visible posts" are the Winners, and thus we know the order of events.