Some of these make more sense at night:


(Player1) cut holes in a bed sheet and spent the night pretending to be a ghost.

(Player1) surfs those websites (his/her1) mother won't let them. 

(Player1) was slain by (Player2), but decided to rise from their grave as a skeleton. 

(Player1) TP's (Player2)'s house.

(Player1) illuminates (Player2)'s face with a flash light, screams, and runs away.

(Player1) falls asleep after a night on the bottle, and (Player2) draws on them with marker.

(Player1), (Player2), and (Player3) have a pillow fight. 

(Player1) and (Player2) settle into a hot tub, and (Player3) watched from the bushes.

(Player1) caught (Player2) by the toe. When (he/she2) hollered, (he/she1) let (him/her2) go.