[quote=@Cynder]
<Snipped quote by Mercenary Lord>
Iwaku has about 300+ users on average from what I've seen. RPNation is definitely the most active of the three, but I'm still not convinced that not everyone on there is a sockpuppet. 
[/quote]

Really...huh. It always seems like whenever I go on Iwaku their active online count is always lower than RPguild. Unless both sites count guests as part of their total count. I just checked Iwaku a few minutes ago, and it said their active count was 245, except about a third of those were guests. If RPG functions the same way, that's one thing, but otherwise I think it's in the middle of the 3

also i tried to do rpnation for a little bit and was plagued with the same issues mentioned in this thread, including disappearing GMs, but also very pretty threads with no substance to them