[@Holy Soldier] He didn't say anything about originality. I think you're confusing "played up" with "played out".

"Played out" means that something is unoriginal, bordering on profoundly mundane. "Played up" means you put a lot of emphasis and attention on something. In your case, you spent... eleven sentences just explaining how incredibly physically adept Wilson is, as compared to other Humans that have been made that put far, FAR less emphasis on incredible supernatural ability.

No one is saying this is a bad thing, just that compared to other Humans, your character is the last anyone would consider to be an "underdog" because of how much you play up his INhuman physical ability.

If I had to pick someone as the average Human underdog, it would be Saxton Cane, because he's just a lawyer.

Well, he's the underdog everywhere BUT the courtroom. He's a competent lawyer.