Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vee
Raw
OP
Avatar of Vee

Vee

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

So I was looking through this Off-Topic thread and didn't see any place for people to post samples of their writing and have fellow writers critique. Though I want to keep this civil and uplifting this is a place for critiques. So take everything with a grain of salt and remember we are all here trying to learn or help others learn.

So feel free to post with some of your writings (or links to writings) and wait for someone to come around with advice. Though I ask if it's more than a few paragraphs to put it in a hider; so it doesn't make each page super long.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vee
Raw
OP
Avatar of Vee

Vee

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

So to get the ball rolling for those who want to advise but not submit samples. I recently wrote a post and would love to have peoples opinions on it. It has been quite a long time since I wrote an intro post this big so I am concerned for it's flow and wording. I would love and appreciate any feed back ^-^

Some back story. This RP is about people who were currently changed into monsters by a Magician type man. My character happens to be a succubus.

Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Revans Exile
Raw
Avatar of Revans Exile

Revans Exile

Banned Seen 8 yrs ago

My one and only critique remove the color. It adds absolutely no value.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vee
Raw
OP
Avatar of Vee

Vee

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

@Revans Exile thank you for the critique. ^-^ I do understand what you mean I am just a sucker for making things pretty. >//<
Hidden 9 yrs ago 5 yrs ago Post by McHaggis
Raw

McHaggis

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Vee
Raw
OP
Avatar of Vee

Vee

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

@McHaggis Thank you so much for the critique. ^-^ I am very glad you liked my post. And Thank you for the idea on what I can do about transition times for flashback scenarios; I never really knew how to properly do that. xD And curse you apostrophes!! You are the bane to my existence! hehe xD
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by VATROU
Raw
Avatar of VATROU

VATROU The Barron

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

I have a Fallout Fan Fic in the Gallery about an NCR expedition into Alaska, although the intro states that they moved their up the coast meeting new Factions or Nations along the way. http://www.roleplayerguild.com/topics/80707-fallout-explorers-of-the-new-world/ooc Here's the thread link, hopefully I can get some input to improve my writing.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Pripovednik
Raw
Avatar of Pripovednik

Pripovednik ☞NO HANDS☜

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

This is my intro to my farcry RP. (Excuse the hiders. On a bad laptop r/n and going to adjust the picture size so i can get rid of the hider) Critique will be appreciated :)

http://www.roleplayerguild.com/topics/81895-far-cry-elobey-isles-brace-for-impact/ooc
Hidden 9 yrs ago 5 yrs ago Post by McHaggis
Raw

McHaggis

Member Seen 4 yrs ago

.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Pripovednik
Raw
Avatar of Pripovednik

Pripovednik ☞NO HANDS☜

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

@McHaggis Thanks! I just wasn't up to checking through it when I wrote it, get it edited soon. Was thinking maybe I could argue they were deliberate and it is a way of making the reader wonder who they are , also because all of the people that read it can't be the same person, the tenses changing reflects that.

Nice to have such nice feed back, thanks bro/broette.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by VATROU
Raw
Avatar of VATROU

VATROU The Barron

Member Seen 2 yrs ago

(I should really put something of mine up. Feels bad doing the constructive criticism with none of the actual receiving it.)

@VATROU
First of all, a disclaimer: I have no experience with Fallout and so I'm just assuming everything on that front is correct ^^
I liked this, for as much as someone who doesn't know anything about the universe can, and my confusion stemmed mostly from my own lack of knowledge. I'm thinking the hook was the ships/initials on the shoulder was the hook? If so it was well placed. I also think the characters shone through with distinct personalities – especially Jonathan and Claire.

The only criticism I feel comfortable giving (as I literally know nothing) is to avoid the exposition at the beginning and spread it throughout the whole piece so far. It seems like too sharp a jump to go from paragraph one of exposition into paragraph two, which is on a small scale location.

Secondly, I think perhaps North's speech at the beginning could be split up rather than be in one blocky paragraph. Perhaps describing the gestures, tone of voice, etc, at one point, or moving how the recruits react to it up and into when he's saying the speech might help with that and make it a little more clear and give it the illusion of length. I think the speech itself was well-written, though.


Technically everything so far regarding my story's setting is neither correct nor incorrect. As it takes place in a fictional setting of my own design. Yes it takes place in the Fallout Universe, but Alaska has almost no precedence save for what is establish Pre-War as in the Great War which ended most life on Earth and set the tone of the franchise. I agree with you on North's speech, I need to work on more nuanced background behaviors. I tend to find articulating different background noises so to speak difficult, as I can't find the words used to describe gestures or sometimes tone. I'm trying to get better and I hope over the course of my Fan Fiction I will improve on those facets.

As for the exposition. I partially agree with you. It would have been more immersive to spread it out, perhaps with the soldier's dialogue. But I also wanted to give a time frame about important events right away so there would be less guessing as to where and when the story takes place.

I am highly grateful for your criticism.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Pripovednik
Raw
Avatar of Pripovednik

Pripovednik ☞NO HANDS☜

Member Seen 8 yrs ago

Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Letter Bee
Raw
Avatar of Letter Bee

Letter Bee Filipino RPer

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Two chapters of an original fic I'm writing. It's a story about Magical Boys and Girls, played straight, no Deconstructions (although I love PMMM), targeted towards, well, people who like Magical Boys and Girls in general; lighthearted Anime Fans. Does it appeal towards that target audience?



Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by mdk
Raw

mdk 3/4

Member Seen 5 yrs ago

Just a quick PSA -- we do have a couple of writing contests active on the forum, where you can write something new (typically along a given theme or challenge) and receive critiques (and we hope you give them, too!). Check out the contest section if you like.
Hidden 9 yrs ago Post by Letter Bee
Raw
Avatar of Letter Bee

Letter Bee Filipino RPer

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Sadly, I don't enjoy formal competitions.
Hidden 9 yrs ago 9 yrs ago Post by Letter Bee
Raw
Avatar of Letter Bee

Letter Bee Filipino RPer

Member Seen 0-24 hrs ago

Deleted.
↑ Top
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet