For now, she wouldn't be punished, but just kept at home so her father could pleasure himself with her, though not outright make love with her. Her father would find out way later after the two had done some secret contacts. He would punish her for daring to love someone outside the Italian/mafia bloodline and for fraternizing with a professional business partner. He would also punish her for trying to hide his relationship with her and as a warning to Nigel himself that Arlia is his to do as he pleases.