[quote=Kidd]
All these plot ideas sound awesome, but it sounds like we'll need more players to carry out most of them.
[/quote]

Perhaps not too many more though, if the Elite Paladins all work as a group, than it's not totally unheard of to have one player control all of them, especially if they're hive-mind or something, not to mention that Hive-mind elite forces trained for one purpose, and carrying out that purpose, is about as scary as it gets, even for bone-ripping creatures of the night. 

An alternative is that as Disbelief starts breaking down, all the supernatural creatures in the area gather to discuss what should be done (like the calm, rational beings that they are), I imagine differences of opinion are settled much more violently in the supernatural community (like the savage, bestial creatures that they are), considering most have a healing factor or invulnerability of some sort, which could lead to some interesting happening. Also this sort of meeting requires only as many characters as we have, (I don't really know what Alex would do, maybe he accidentally wanders in, or is there as a sort of finger food, or as proof that disbelief is breaking down, or maybe Lilah brought him to make sure that everybody gets a fair shake including the humans.......) and this allows more to be added, just saying they arrived late, or they were really quiet during the first bit, or they were sleeping etc.