[quote=Jangel13]I just had to deal with my first argument as the gm of a roleplay.[/quote]

Welcome to the wonderful yet chaotic world of GM'ing, there will be far more to come. May you be an amazing GM or not, so thankfully the better you are the less often then things are bound to pop up.

As for the specific issue, I'm really just left with a lack of info atm to really say. Was the similar character just by chance? Was it intentional? How long was this similar character in the works before the original demanded for a change?