I'm a PS4 player. I bought XBox 360 and played a few games, always had fun I suppose, but I just used my PlayStation more and so that's where I wound up. I think I liked the controller better; it's not for everyone, so no biggie, this is just where I landed.

I don't have an XB1 yet, but I've used one at my friend's place just a little bit. The voice controls are pretty awesome. And, for all the crap they got for their E3 presentation, the TV and social connections are actually kind of cool. It's not something you thought you wanted, but it's cool. 

Game selection, controller comfort, networking, etc. are going to come down to your preferences, and what your friends are doing. I love my PS4 -- I think the technical specs are *ever so slightly* on Sony's side, but not in any really significant way that's gonna bother you during play. X-Box One looks like X-Box Fun to me, so knock yourself out, I say.