I understand how this works in regards to average Joes, but I think it's something Fallen Muse needs to make a judgement call on. It really limits those of us playing Hunter characters.

After all, these are people who know full well that werewolves exist, and it creates a major unfair situation if we have to curl up and scream every tinge a Crinos arrives on the scene. It also makes no sense that an experienced Hunter would try and "rationalize" a werewolf sighting.

It may work within the context of the original game, but I think it really messes things up for a written roleplay.