Eunuch it is then.

I was talking about the tactician trait. Having to figure out working strategies as we go along. Genius is more like something you're born with (unless you're Rock Lee).
But... If you're willing to drop the genius trait I don't see anything wrong with you taking the tactician... Of course you won't start out as Shikamaru, instantly figuring out weak spots and correct strategies that hinges on Kakashi following you to the fight despite never telling him about it...