MY TURN! Just happened...

Western RP. My char, made out to be a legend from the start (as in, super talented with her gun despite possibly (Note is says possibly, not that she is) being blind). 

She gets a wanted man to help her find his old gang after said man escaped from prison and tried to steal her horse. 
They meet another man who is her friend (another criminal, but low end). He upsets the bad guy with her.
The partner decides to just shoot him and tear out part of his throat doing so... Auto-hit/kill you could say.

I respond making my character draw her pistol first and fire a shot that hits the gun to knock it off aim and miss the man. He's an important character, so an auto-hit that will end in death is not okay. More so, in my post, she explains to him that this man's entire gang, which is very large and already known to be above in the rocks above them will just begin shooting him right then and there in retaliation. More so, SHE would kill him if he touches the man because it's her friend. So, allowing the hit would end the RP because he would then be killed by either the extremely large gang surrounding them or she'd do it herself.

And if he wanted to fight 'speed', I agreed with him she couldn't swing her rifle around from her back in time, but she is known for her pistol draw. Adding to it, his character is supposed to be dehydrated, tired, hungry, etc. So, she'd be able to draw faster than he'd be able to aim the rifle and fire, logically.

But, of course, he quit after this.

I always find it funny when someone tries a BIG auto-hit/kill on an important character and then get mad when you try to, in character, dodge and explain why it wouldn't work out correctly...or out of character. Either way.

Oh well. One more RP down. o-o