[quote=manapool1]
no books,see his character has just gotten into town
[/quote]

[quote=1Charak2]
Books they came in after the spell has been worked call it timing but if u truely need him to fall asleep i can work that in to his post
[/quote]

If Charak's characters have just gotten into town just as the spell had been cast upon the entire city, then it only makes sense that they fall asleep like the others, but they'll just be at the edge of the town. Basically, you were at the wrong place at just the right time.