[quote=Jorick]
I'd guess it's the dude's face. That looks like a super fake smile, and he has dead person eyes. I suppose that's enough for an image to be creepy to pansies.
[/quote]

I admit it looks like a guy fake smiling. ...But fake smiles are just... I mean people fake smile all the time. Just because someone's not good at it doesn't make them creepy. 

Maybe it only sets off certain people.