[quote=LillyDove]
It's early, normally I would not say anything but I think that you are really being a bit harsh in viewing his CS. And it is coming across like you don't want his character or rather you don't want him to have another character. If so, why? This harshness is kind of annoying, and this early in the morning I don't filter what I say, so maybe keep that in mind when you reply?Thanks so much. :P
[/quote]

It wasn't meant to be harsh. I could be way harsher with reviewing to be fair. I review by pointing things out and asking for either details or some changes. It may look like that, but I am keen on not using strong words or anything that could give the image that it was a harsh review. Maybe it came over like that due the lot of things I questioned and requested to changed, but that is merely cause it would be wrong to just think ''I already have asked five things to be changed, I will let this one slide''. That would give him some hard time when another GM notices his Cs has some faults and make me look like a bad reviewer, due being overly nice.

Another note is that a reviewer needs to be objective and not subjective. This means that even though having nothing against Alternathan, I can't bypass things. It would be unfair to everybody else, including him.