Hearing Hayley say that she wanted to return his feelings for her, Isaac can't help but gaze at her in surprise. He had been so certain, after who knows how long of things not going his way, that she would laugh in his face and kick him out, that this possibility had never really occurred to him. Still holding her hand, his sandwich all but forgotten, he leans in a bit closer, his cheeks feeling so warm, he wouldn't be surprised if they caught fire, and quietly asks, "A-are you saying that you...you feel the same way?"