The dub was only disappointing to many since Madoka's voice actor took a high pitched helium voice style rahter than her own spin. Christine Cabonos is a good voice actor shown with Azu-nyan in K-On. But she fell flat compared to everyone else.

I liked the english dub better since Christina Vee did a great job along with Laura Landa and Sarah Williams, yes for realz, while Mami could've been better (she fell a bit low when the breakdown occurred.) She did well for the most part.