Derp... I just remembered that I already organized the "Movies" tab of my list to include all the movies I've seen, as I've watched them in a ranked order from 1st all the way to last... In other words I made this list a long time ago and forgot.

10. Hot Fuzz
I actually just watched this yesterday, it just happened to claim the number 10 spot because I liked it more than now #11, but not as much as #9. XD
9. Bad Santa
8. Shawn of the Dead
7. Paul
6. Batman Begins
5. Serenity
4. The Hobbit
3. Lord of the Rings
2. The Karate Kid 
Both new and old. I have a [u]slight[/u] preference towards Old, but there both such great movies in my mind.
1. Batman: The Dark Knight