[quote=Schradinger]
But summoning light from stars, sand from nothing, and having a body composed entirely of metal is perfectly legit. See what I mean about a confusing double standard?
[/quote]

The presence of powers is the suspension of disbelief. The effect of those powers on other people and on the environment around them is still very much real. You also stated that Paige wasn't immune to the damage that energy does on the body. It's not a double standard.

Also, if I get shot by a gun seven times, I won't be more resilient. If I got shot an eighth time, it is going to hurt just as much as it did when I was first shot.