[quote=Tatsua Aiisen]Because it's not possible in the universe you're placing this roleplay in.[/quote]

Fictional Universe, which I made a fictional alteration to. I really don't see how it's that different from a retcon of characters.
Especially when the shows excuse was as weak as "Girls are more emotional" when there are many guys who are very emotional, and many girls who aren't that emotional. It would make more sense just to say anyone within ______ emotional hormone level as a requirement rather than restrict it by their genitalia.

[quote=Tatsua Aiisen]I'll stop mentioning it though, if only because I know you'll just kick me from the roleplay if I continue to stress it.[/quote]

I don't kick people for having a different opinion. I only kick people if there are halting progress in the RP, were warned to stop and kept doing it anyways.

[quote=Tatsua Aiisen]Some quick questions,
1: Is Kyubey in this? Or is it just another Incubator?
2: Will you be playing as the veteran of the group, or are you expecting a player to?
3: Will there be NPC magical girls, without spoiling anything?[/quote]

1: Considering the Retcon it's only appropriate it would be another Incubator. But since Incubators rely on logic alone and lack any emotion they will probably act essentially the same way.

2: It's open to anyone atm who wishes to make a Veteran character. But if no one wishes to then I will be providing a Veteran Character.

3: NPC magical girls will be provided as needed by the RP. The direction we take might demand I make several, it might demand I never make any.