The last painting that Riley showed Alex was one that hit him more in an emotional sense. She wanted him to have it and so he took the painting from her and looked at the scene painted in front of him. He did remember that night, leaving Rick's parents with a large medical bill for their son, the ensuing trouble with the police until charges were dropped and the promise Riley made to him which he had taken to heart. His thoughts then rushed to how their relationship hit a slump after that night. The anger he felt at how she treated him differently for coming and helping her, as if he had done the wrong thing. He raised his eyebrows at the thought and shook his head. After that day, Alex's performance in school declined, as far as his track record went at least. He began being bullied by others and would often "get" into fights when he was really trying to defend himself. Not only at school but even at home Riley began to talk to him less and less and they spent less time with each other. Mentally, he shook off the bad thoughts and looked up at Riley, "Thanks." He told her in regards to her gifting him the painting, "It's great." He added, commenting on the craftsmanship.

Alex placed the canvas down against the wall, separate from the others, he would take this one home with him. When Riley began to apologize Alex stopped her, shaking his head and gesturing with his hand. "You don't have to apologize." He paused, "We were just kids." He added. Alex walked over to the counter and placed his empty glass down. It was unlike Alex to feel a sort of anger. It wasn't the type of anger that would leave someone shouting and hitting inanimate objects but rather a type that crushed you. He pursed his lips and then sat at the table, facing Riley he smiled again. "It was my fault anyway." He told her. "I took it too far that night and it had consequences for you. I accept that."