[quote=Robeatics]
You act as if your contention is somehow at all logical and befitting of the premises, and thereby some kind of law that has to be fulfilled by every single premise in order for any of them to be correct. I don't even know what you're trying to argue beyond to say that what Asta is saying does not coincide with YOUR OWN idea of the justice system.
[/quote]

How do the premises I stated not entail the conclusion?

And, I outright stated the premises may be false, but one must be or premise 4 must be.