[quote=MiddleEarthRoze]
Yourself? I'm sorry, hon, but you're the one who's been treating others like crap. Admittedly, on Soren's first sign-up, I myself came off as a bit harsh, but I apologized and told him that wasn't my intention. However, you don't seem to care about your harsh words, despite the fact that they are quite hypocritical. I seem to recall you complaining that his second character sign-up had too many skills and abilities, despite the fact that they were quite similar to my own character's abilities, and mine was accepted. You, with the character of a ''natural genius, excels at every subject...'', complaining about abilities of another? Wow. Pot calling the kettle black much? Personally, I find you antagonizing, and the GM isn't helping by giving you special treatment. At first I was hesitant to believe that she was, so when I called you out - quite correctly- on your raven thing, she dismissed it, as you'd already been accepted, and had already posted in the IC.Yeah, we have an edit button for a reason.I'm happy to leave this RP, as it's been wrecked by the attitudes of yourself and the GM, who blame it on others when we complain about you.Good day. Kindly delete my character sign-up.
[/quote]

I didn't seem to care about my harsh words because I didn't really realize they were harsh. I simply replied with what I've seen in hundreds of roleplays before this one, a simple, straight-forward character review. And I certainly have never attacked or abused another player, even when they've been flaming me or insulting my work. If somebody wanted to complain about me, they should have politely brought the subject up with me, so that we could have peacefully and intelligently resolved this conflict before it happened.

[hider=Regarding Characters]Charlotte and Magnus are hardly similar cases. Charlotte, while talented, has no rare abilities or items and is generally abysmal at schoolwork, research and anything requiring long periods of intense concentration. She shows her unusual potential very infrequently, as her general lack of drive prevents her from accomplishing much. 

Shaman is nothing extraordinary, he's a magical Raven that was taught to speak by her father and who bonded with Charlotte when she was very young. He can talk, and is good at reciting and recompiling the obscure variety of tips and jokes he's learned from his original master. Also, contrary to what I think you believe, all of this information was disclosed with the GM prior to Charlotte being accepted.

The old Magnus, on the other hand, was both a Metamorphmagus and a natural Animagus along with possessing a rare wand. It's an extraordinary combination of three extremely rare traits, one of which is normally only possible for high-level and extremely dedicated witches and wizards. Balance-wise, it doesn't really matter, it's more that from a lore standpoint such a thing is unheard off and a little absurd. Once he removed the natural Animagus thing, I was totally fine with his CS, there was just a bit of a miss-communication that lead to him thinking he was denied. It's worth noting that when he posted his CS, there had already been another Metamorphmagus posted and accepted. Such an ability is so rare, it's crazy to think that two would be going to school on the same year. That doesn't matter much, though~!

On the note of your character, there were no real issues with it. I'm not sure what else to say, but that as a half-blood you would probably be more likely to be born a Metamorphmagus. Apple is hardly a rare wand wood, and being able to eventually become an Animagus isn't completely absurd if you were already studying it and dedicated a lot of time to learning the correct process.[/hider]