[quote=Legend]
You'd have to have an exception regarding all non-resource collectors. And if you change it so their job only has to contain their assigned element, then it would be virtually no different than today's society, except with more confusion. Because Spirit needs his memories of us =,(
[/quote]

More confusion for a society not adapted to those traditions. I'm telling you, it could work. Not for really long times, but it could work nonetheless.