[quote=KatherinWinter]
I don't understand'How should I know the truth of any matter yet?'
[/quote]

Well, how well does he know either of them? He could probably pretend to be swayed. Although, the whole 'torture' bit is probably a dead giveaway... [s]Totally not just improvising poorly.[/s] 

...Or I might just be crazy. Should I just change it?