Plus, the clumsy doctor archetype isn't one I see much on RPs. I've personally RPed with people who've done a cocky doctor, and a fairly well done Badass doctor. They were both in action heavy RPs, but my only problem with them was that they all too often acted incredibly serious when they didn't need to. I prefer more silly characters over the incredibly bland serious ones. It's why I never liked Cloud but absolutely loved Zidane when it came to FF protagonists.

Then what would those poorly made characters equate too? Barnacles on the side of an abandoned old ship out at sea?