Personally, I think that a critiquing of posts is a good thing. So maybe not a grade that affects the points one would get from their fight. But, we could add an optional tag for those that would like their fights looked at and some extra help. Or maybe I’m alone on this; I always enjoy others helping me become better at writing. I’m also a fan of getting points based on wins/losses, that way one loss doesn’t all of a sudden drop you to the bottom. 

Thinking it over I think that if we choose Player or Character grading will depend on if we set it up as a persistent world or not. If we make it more of an ‘Arena’ RP, than character grading makes more sense. But if we simply take the RP out and make it Arena battles than I think Player graded makes more sense.