Anyways, something to think about for future plot points. I was thinking of basically giving every character here a sort of 1v1 fight against, say, a rival, a special enemy, or what have you. Basically, this will give everyone their own time to shine, however, the player of that character will be the one who decides what leads up to it, who/what the enemy is, and even when it happens in the RP. We'll do that via PM, so the others don't have plot points spoiled for them.

Also, just for the funnies: 
Guy 1: "Welcome to the table, how tough are ya?" 
Guy 2: "How tough am I? HOW TOUGH AM I? I beat a dragon in one attack!"
Guy 1: "So?" 
Guy 2: "I rolled a 1." 
Guy 1: "Oh, uh, go right ahead, sir, enjoy your stay."