[quote=@Rilla]
I don't think they should just pop up sort a new sword all Willy nilly because they lost the last one. Otherwise wagering may as well be off the table. 
[/quote]

I'm mainly saying for things like a steel sword that you could logically find almost anywhere. It's kind of their fault for accepting a wager for such a common item or they just want that character's for whatever reason. Maybe to add insult to injury. Now if you were wagering the ultimate sword of dragon exploding then you'd not be able to justify finding another one.