[@Sep]
[quote=@HeySeuss]
Yeah, the pirates, like Slooga, are not the focus of the RP. Characters need to be members of the platoon. If your character wants to go from pirate to platoon, that works, though I'm not sure how it'd work if he were intruder crew. Maybe they took him as a replacement when he pissed off Slooga, and the platoon was like, "Welp, he's army. So he's our concern, not yours."
[/quote]

While the character would fit in strongly if this were based on the ship and a pirate crew, I think I need to stick with the original line that this is an RP about the platoon and that your character, as stands, would be good supporting cast, but I don't want to have to stretch the narrative thin writing him into the RP or with lots of lag times between moments when he is relevant.

That's generally why I want characters to be a part of 1st Platoon, formally (or droids owned by them, though we've cut that off at what we have.)

It's a good character as a supporting cast, but doesn't make sense as a member of the 1st Platoon.