Wrong. She's 10.5 years old :D

She'd also dug herself a grave had she been dealing with bandits or cannibals. But luckily, it happened to be Annette's group.

Has nothing to do with her acting. She acted in an Adam Sandler comedy for Christ's sake.

It has more to do with spending 6 months outside, being taught by someone not opposed to such things and being desperate.

She'd also made a ton of mistakes. Making noise in the vents, not waiting for the boy to leave, shouting, dealing with the boy poorly, sshooting, did not kill the man in one shot, and the worst of it all is that she trapped herself. Being unable to deal with her situation well, which lead her to commit all these mistakes in the first place. And the biggest mistake of them all is that she's assaulting an otherwise friendly group. Heck, she couldn't even talk right after all she'd been through and she'd failed in all her objectives despite having the element of surprise and superior firepower, how about you put it that way?

I'm under the impression actually that most of the characters could approach the situation better in her shoes. David or Ames would have left everyone dead and be gone very quickly rather than causing a scene. Or heck, most of the characters would have come up with a diplomatic solution that's far less risky.

I tried my best ever since the conception of the character to make her a realistic young survivor who might be skilled but is otherwise young and inexperienced and broken and so will make mistakes and bad decisions.

Anyway, we'll let our Pal be the judge.