[quote=@IncredibleBee]I thought it was obvious that you'd need to be choosy when sending someone to greet Guts more than basically anyone else, more so when he pulled out the death threats. At the very least, I'd thought you'd read up. I don't recall you asking if it was a good idea to send a specific type of character, either.[/quote]

Er... Berserk's a bit long to read up just to try and work out what won't set Guts off. Not to mention not everyone's cup of tea. XD
 
[quote=@IncredibleBee]Also, I instagibbed her like a faceless mook NPC because she kind of is one. No character sheet, and no real details. She doesn't even have a name.
[/quote]

That's because there was no chance for them to give a name. If they're on their own, not attacking you, and trying to talk, you're above 'faceless mook'--or if they bring along mooks of their own. When one post is specifically 'no, they're not dead', it's pretty clear from context they're not a mook.