[quote=@IncredibleBee]In the face of powers like these, I feel like an antimagic melee weapon isn't a ridiculous concept.
[/quote]

And it didn't seem antimagic at all until it became relevant, which is more problematic than knowing what people can do beforehand. That the mechanism exploits something that only applies in Berserk and would allow it to destroy things that can't be destroyed is an issue. (Excalibur comes to mind as a specific example)


[quote=@Earnest Evans]
I think what we're missing is how [@IncredibleBee] had "The Dragonslayer destroys magic" listed on his character sheet [i]all this time,[/i] and he's not even the only character with a weapon that ignores defenses, either. If we had any issues with this, it would have been best to call them out [i]beforehand[/i][/quote]

Exact quote: "By slaying countless monsters, the sword has taken on magical properties, and can now harm magical beings that can't be hurt by mundane weapons". It isn't explicitly negating [i]any magical anything[/i].