([i]Oh boy, a lot of this stuff coming from Robin is from that RP I had. ^^'[/i])

[center][img]http://38.media.tumblr.com/32a0913220cb5e69eb623152da7518d9/tumblr_inline_nifrgjwUx41sfvecc.png[/img]

[color=DarkSlateBlue]"So you're advancing a theory that hasn't been said yet? I'd like to challenge that!"[/color] Robin doubted that this theory of Battler's would be able to pull this game into a draw, holding out his tome as he charged energy for a spell.

Even Dlanor had the same doubts as Robin considering that Battler hasn't said his theory yet.

[color=Thistle]"Then let me ASK! If it's not Natsuhi, who is the CULPRIT?"[/color] This needed to be clarified if they were going to have a good footing against this theory that was soon to come around.

[img]http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/umineko/images/a/a4/But_d11_odoroki1.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/400?cb=20140727085554[/img]

[color=DarkRed]"[/color][color=RoyalBlue][b]It's possible to everything with the revenge of the baby from nineteen years ago,[/b][/color][color=DarkRed]"[/color] Both of them clashed blades again, making no room for error or even a sign of rest.

[img]http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/umineko/images/9/95/Dla_b23b_ikari1.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/626?cb=20140125154012[/img]

[color=thistle]"[/color][color=Red][b]Knox's 1st. It is forbidden for the culprit to be anyone not mentioned in the early part of the STORY! A person first introduced in the fifth game can't be named as the CULPRIT![/b][/color][color=Thistle]"[/color]

[img]http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/umineko/images/b/bc/But_d11_majime7.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/400?cb=20140725053053[/img]

[color=DarkRed]"[/color][color=Blue][b]But what if the baby was one of us since the beginning?[/b][/color][color=DarkRed]"[/color] Battler locked his blade against Dlanor's, taking a moment just to think if he should go on with this [color=RoyalBlue][b]Blue Truth[/b][/color], and then finally saying,[color=DarkRed]"[/color][color=RoyalBlue][b]For example... if it's [i]me[/i]!?[/b][/color][color=DarkRed]"[/color]

While it was settled that it was something that could be plausible, Robin was quick to counter it immediately, since he had the knowledge of certain events through the help of Dlanor.

[img]http://33.media.tumblr.com/bce5f18c5c592c0c880a61fa9ba0fe7f/tumblr_inline_navtx5GYAW1sfvecc.jpg[/img]

[color=DarkSlateBlue]"Impossible.[/color] [color=Red][b]Battler Ushiromiya is an 18 year old man, meaning that he was not alive at the time of Natsuhi's actions 19 years ago. Along with this, I also know the 'crime' that Natsuhi committed,[/b][/color] [color=RoyalBlue]one that by it's very nature excludes Battler due to the nature of time![/color][color=DarkSlateBlue]"[/color] For a moment, you could see a small smirk on Robin's face, as if he were telling them that he was on the spot with this game.

[color=DarkSlateBlue]"[/color][color=Red][b]Natsuhi had agreed to adopt a baby, most likely the supposed man from 19 years ago, but refused for mysterious reasons.[/b][/color][color=DarkSlateBlue] The reason I have reached this conclusion[/color][color=Red][b]is that the man from 19 years ago calls Natsuhi 'mother' as an insult because of her abandoning him![/b][/color] [color=RoyalBlue][b]Simply put, it is ridiculous to say that Battler Ushiromiya was the man from 19 years ago as for one, he had most likely not even been conceived in his mother's womb, and as for two, if he was meant to be adopted but was subsequently abandoned by Natsuhi, the whole family would have known and a scandal would have broken out unless Kinzo Ushiromiya covered it up. Even then, there would have been rumors yet it seems the only individuals to know her 'crime' are herself and the man.[/b][/color][color=DarkSlateBlue]"[/color]

Seeing that Dlanor would say something, Robin held out a hand to show that he wasn't done just yet,[color=DarkSlateBlue]"Before you quote Knox's Decalogue, hear this![/color] [color=Red][b]Battler Ushiromiya knows that he is not the man from 19 years ago! The 9th law protects me in this instance because Battler has been withholding knowledge of the case![/b][/color][color=DarkSlateBlue] Even if he was, why would he help Natsuhi kill members of the family? Why wouldn't he kill simply Natsuhi, her husband, and her progeny before moving on to the rest of the family if he so desired?"[/color]

[img]http://33.media.tumblr.com/c538fe9cc89a18bdb945e8e1cc49fd00/tumblr_inline_nifrglN9qw1sfvecc.png[/img]

He turned to Battler, a glint of satisfaction in his eyes, [color=DarkSlateBlue]"Go on, Sorcerer, disprove my words. I want to see your desire to survive in your eyes.​"[/color]

Instead of casting out a spell from the fact that he held out a tome to use, this much of the Truths being used here caused his spell to become a beam of the [color=Red][b]Red[/b][/color] and [color=RoyalBlue][b]Blue[/b][/color] Truths aimed for Battler and Sora.

[img]http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/umineko/images/d/db/But_d11_aseru2.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/400?cb=20140725052242[/img]

[color=DarkRed][sub]"... d-dammit,"[/sub][/color] Battler muttered, not expecting this outsider to rip apart the foundation to his theory just like that. The other resort would be to use the Truth that he now knows about Beatrice's games... judging that using himself as the culprit wouldn't exactly work anymore.

[hr]

[color=LightBlue]"... just... wa... it... until... everyone else... around... here... finds..o... ut"[/color] Erika managed to say, seeing that it was useless to try and wiggle her way out of this.[/center]