[quote=@Lugubrious]
Hey [@HereComesTheSnow] I permit friendly joshing but a contingency of similarly-themed posts is more like harassment.  Plank, you can't demonize RT for not 'going all out casting this'.  RWBY was a startup project of a little studio in Texas, they didn't get the luxury of nabbing the best voice actors in the business.  Personally, I don't give a crap about who voices it in Japanse; it'll never be anything more than charming for me because I don't understand Japanese.  If you two feel like puffing yourselves up about the superiority your opinions by jumping down someone's throat for their [i]personal opinion[/i] (which will doubtlessly include mine now) then you can take it to PMs and have a stroke-fest there.  This discussion is over.
[/quote]


So wait

I'm confused

How is ending the argument with easily the most inflammatory statements [i]in[/i] the argument better than 'a contingent of similarly themed posts' (contingent, for the record, doesn't mean 'two'. That'd be the worst contingent of all time), when the person responding to that contingent of posts (Three, for the record, and slightly higher if you're being generous with where the argument started) compares the people expressing a perfectly valid viewpoint to [i]Nazis[/i]?

One one side, we have a relatively civil (aside from one picture) analysis of why the dub won't suck; not "English version sucks", just that the Japanese one won't. And in fact, by your own reasoning, [i]does[/i] have a better VA cast. On the other side we have comparisons to [i]Nazis, scathing comments about opinions, and telling your players to go have a stroke-fest in their own PMs.[/i] In a manner intended to end it.

So yeah.

I'm confused where you've got the moral high ground. But GM privilege means you get to end that line of thought right there, so.