[quote=@Gnar The Missing Link]Edit: Also, made my GM Post and gave some more hints for the puzzle- this time a bit more direct. Along with making things a tad more interesting for everyone to have some free reign for a bit because freedom is nice.
[/quote]

Huh. Turns out the others' guess was right, and the hat boy was the right statue. Personally thought it was the Rifleman because it sort of makes sense that a Rifleman would be made out of Iron? 

Well, wrong guess aside, woo for straight answers.